Circle of Christhood

The Study of Joel Goldsmith's Infinite Way

New Name


This page was at one time, The Disobedient.  Because students did not like this label,  a new descriptor needed to be found. The most impersonal term which came to mind was "Non-Norman Letter."  So, for now, we will use this term to describe those teachers and others who do not follow Joel's instructions about teaching ONLY with HIS books and tapes.  Thank you for your patience and understanding.

For Joel's Infinite Way


The following page of information is presented in a factual, objective way.  Some may think that in The Infinite Way we are not to be critical. This is true. We never label or condemn a man as being good, bad, a sinner, etc. We recognize human discords as Error and we do not give it power.   However, Joel alters this instruction a bit when it comes to spiritual people "in high places."  He considers spiritual "mischief" to be tatamount to murder, even worse, for murder just deals with the body. It is to educate newcomers to The Infinite Way that these statements are being made.

What you are about to read will not be comfortable for some of you. There is no wish to cause anyone harm or unhappiness, just a desire to be honest and help new students in the work find accurate resources.  The comments may seem judgmental or critical, but they are simply facts which may be researched and confirmed by any student. (Please report any inaccuracies immediately to the Guestbook and changes will be made.)

If you do not wish to know about those who claim to represent the principles and practice of The Infinite Way, but are making mistakes in their work, please read no further.

The hope is that this information will serve students looking to study The Infinite Way accurately as taught by Joel Goldsmith.  It is not for anyone but Infinite Way students seeking Joel's authentic teaching. This site is the only place you will read these comments. They are not for the "public." They are not published outside of this website.  The statements are solely based on the opinions and experiences of this author.

Students who do not care about accuracy or authenticity, and who like their affiliations with those named, please know we support you and wish you well. We make no claim to judge for you what is correct in your study.



Our Prayer for Those Who Claim to Be Higher in Consciousness Than Joel

Each year more and more students will want to become teachers of The Infinite Way. You may get mailers or find people online.  Some may have a short history with the work, it is hard to know from websites and mailers. Some may have studied only the books.  Insist on a teacher that knows most of the tapes and continues to study them themselves every day.  Teachers must heal. Teachers must know how to teach you meditation.  Do not rest until you find one loyal to Joel.

Everyone mentioned here is a member of our spiritual household regardless of their behavior.  We are not judging them, but rather analyzing their actions. Since students are vulnerable, it is important that they have the information they need to make a wise choice.  Ultimately, they will be led from within.  Meditating on the proper teacher, asking for God to guide and direct you will insure that you find the right place.

It is with great hope that we include all here in our prayers.  We know that they are the Christ and that any inharmonious behavior is simply error operating.  With this realization, we can dissolve the appearances and lift the consciousness of all involved.  You are invited to join us in healing prayer.

The desire to honor God and Truth is evident throughout our fellow seekers.  We hold all here very close in meditation so that we can be one in Joel's spiritual household.

Some readers will feel that our statement of names and activities is a form of criticism or condemnation, on the contrary.  We hope that with new understandings of Joel's instructions in the Letter to Norman (no tapes or books to be used but those of Joel), many will begin to re-evaluate their activities and re-align themselves with Joel's teachings.  It is important for us all to know which activities are in tune with Joel's.  This can only be done by presenting information openly and honestly.

Perhaps many here did not know of Joel's letter and wishes.  (See Norman Letter on this site.)  Once we realize his wishes, it is a simple thing to begin teaching according to those instructions.  One can simply adjust the teaching practice to only use Joel's books and tapes when teaching the Infinite Way. 

If the instructor wants to use other materials, even that of the teacher's personal information or unfoldment, it is only correct to name that separately and teach it as a different philosophy.  Joel was the model for us here. When new things were revealed to him in Christian Science, he left to teach under his own name, The Infinite Way.  The Infinite Way is Joel's message.  It is not the only message of truth.  So, if we have our individual understanding of spiritual truth, this is wonderful and a blessing.  We must, however, give it our own name and prove our principles. To usurp Joel's teaching is unacceptable. To claim you can add to the Infinite Way is saying your consciousness is higher than Joel's. Joel operated under Divine instruction. He was told that the Infinite Way was complete and that is when he also was told to get his things in order and leave, which he did - missing a vacation he so looked forward to in Scotland.

As we  become familiar with Joel's teachings, we realize that Joel's few instructions were never meant to control what a student read.  They were meant to keep teachers in tune with Joel's consciousness and thereby, with each other.  A good analogy here is the way Jewish synagogues all read the same page of the Torah each Friday night regardless of where they are in the world.  The scriptural passage is the same everywhere and usually in Hebrew. Thus, the teaching has lasted with great accuracy for thousands of years. (See the Dead Sea Scroll scholarship on this topic.) Also, if a Jew is forced to flee to another city or country, he is never lost in his spiritual studies. He can easily join in the spiritual activities of his new community.

On the other hand, Christianity has been interpreted and re-interpreted, translated and re-translated, one Bible after another, until today the original teaching of Jesus is almost completely lost. This is what Joel was concerned with. That with added interpretations, the holy message brought forth through him would be lost and hidden.  We must all play our part in keeping his message as it was recorded.  Infinite Way teachers are charged with an even greater responsibility.


If we can agree that we are devoted not to a person, not to a name, but to the highest teaching on earth, then we can easily find a way to honor the revelator by striving to closely follow his teaching and do our part to further the path of truth for future generations. Those new to the work have very little, sometimes no information to reference, no history to understand, no guidelines for their studies.  In this light, we offer our current information and hope that soon, all here will be studying and teaching The Infinite Way with our revelator, Joel's tapes and books.

No comments here are to be taken as personal attacks. We list only those who have declared themselves active in The Infinite Way.  We  have received their advertising, found their business cards, spoken with them, or read their letters and websites. They each announce and advertise that they have materials to sell, and/or are in some way ordained in the work - either by Joel himself or through the contact with one so chosen.  

We hope the information given here will be a way for students to discern for themselves who teaches The Infinite Way.

Liberty Becomes License


Listening to tape 606 side 2 made by Joel in 1951, we are brought to issues of The Infinite Way today.  Joel compares the Hebrews in the days of Moses to our own Americans struggling in the 1960's for freedom from slavery. Without education, liberty becomes chaos and those freed run "wild".  Moses, when faced with the raging, heathen Hebrews brought forth the Law, The Ten Commandments.

In our work, many interpret the sacred teaching of "I" to be that each individual has personal freedom to do what they like (license).  The spiritual freedom Joel taught has been misunderstood or never learned correctly. Thanks to the original teachers who distorted Joel's lessons for their own personal benefit and gain, we face the mixing we have today.

When we feel that we, of ourselves, know more than Joel, and that we can add to The Infinite Way, we are reliving the tale of the Prodigal Son.  It is classic and one of the aspects of the mysterious Fall of Man.  Man felt he did not need his Father, he was capable of deciding for himself, finding his own way, making his own decisions - no more rules, no more constraints or restrictions.  We know the tragic path he traveled. We are still on it in this world, trying to find our way home to the Father's House.

Please see what is going on and know that it is with love for Joel and The Infinite Way, and love for you, dear student, that this list exists and will be maintained.  My only desire is that you are led back to the truth of the revealed message, not to humans excusing away their egos.

Please note, Joel allowed  photographs when pressed for them by publishers, but later stopped it. He did not think students were helped by emphasizing personality and appearance. This is why there is notation below for those who are using photographs. They do not serve a spiritual function.



From Joel's February 16, 1964 Hotel Talk, Unedited


If you remember what we had this morning on tape number 4, side 2, Honolulu Infinite Way Study Center 1964, there is only one thing that can be added to that and I will not have to say too much about it because we had the subject recently, and that is SECRECY.  The vital art of this practice is the ability to keep It locked up within you and perform it and practice it without ever speaking of It to anyone.  Never under any circumstances let It come through your lips until such time as you have completed the demonstration and are fully living in the consciousness that enables you automatically to turn within every hour of the day, every quarter hour of the day, and realize that right here where you are, in the midst of your meal, at any moment, you can turn within and you will be FLOODED with whatever you need - - inspiration, light, wisdom, principles, courage, foresight, judgment, integrity.  Whatever it is that may be the need of the moment, you just have to blink your eyes and immediately
I HAVE ACCESS to all that God has. 

When you are demonstrating this in your life and the fruitage is apparent, then you can begin to teach it and impart it to others, but not before.  If you try to tell it or teach it before you have demonstrated It, you will be telling something to someone else that you have not proven and you will lose your Self respect by setting yourself up as a teacher of something you do not know - - or pretending that something is a principle which you have not demonstrated.  At first there will be those who will tell you that it is selfishness, that you must “give everything you have.”  No!  Just because you know about It does not mean that you have attained the consciousness of It.  Spiritually, never give that which you have not attained.  If you learn of a principle that seems reasonable to you, practice it until your life shows it forth.  Then when someone is led to you, you can share it because it will then multiply itself.  The more you teach what you really know, the more it will multiply itself, but what you try to give another before you are ready, diminishes, and you have less of it.

Do you not see why I had to sit with this Message as a practitioner in an office for sixteen years before I could teach it, and before a book was written?  There were sixteen years of practice before the first book was written, and then no one could deny or refute the principles of The Infinite Way or they would have been in the position the church was in when it said the world was not round after Christopher Columbus returned from his voyage.  Yes, there were sixteen years before the first book, and then another seventeen years in which the Message has gone around the world.

That is how you must be individually, until It is such a part of your life that it is a very living witness of It.  Until then, do not teach anyone because you have nothing to teach.  Spiritual teaching comes out of an ATTAINED CONSCIOUSNESS, not out of an intellectual knowledge.  Anyone with a quick mind can read these books and memorize these principles, but there is no power in reading or memorizing.  One reviewer of a recent Infinite Way book said there is one thing that has to be said about this Message:  “The author himself is convinced that it is Truth.”  And back in the “old days” I used to write articles that were called didactic.  Why?  Because I stated principles with positive conviction, which is the only way in which spiritual teaching can be fruitful.  Until you have arrived at the point of CONVICTION, do not try to teach - - and the only worthwhile conviction is that which is based on demonstration.  “By their fruits ye shall know them.”  Until then, stay alone, even if you too have to wait sixteen years.  A strange thing about Truth is that IT really does not have to be spoken.  Once you have an inner CONVICTION of It, It shines out of your inner Being to those who are receptive.

This brings us to what might be called the very height of mysticism:  Spiritually you are imparting only when you are in SILENCE, when there is no activity of the conscious thinking mind taking place.  You can prove it in this way:  Take plants or birds or animals or infants, and sit by them in an absolute STILLNESS, not attempting to impart with the mind or through thoughts, but with an attentive receptivity:  “Speak, Lord, thy servant heareth.”  Then hear!  As you sit in that listening attitude, with no attempt to impart, you are imparting It.  You will notice that you have better crops and that the birds and animals and infants RESPOND.  Eventually you will also find adults who are responsive and receptive.
 

From the July 7, 1963 Unedited Hotel Talk

Joel reminds us of Jesus' comment:

 "His mission was not to build up a name for Himself.  In other words, "This Message is not Mine but His that sent Me."

We are simply underscoring this lesson again. It is not about "Joel" the man, it is about the teachings of the Christ Consciousness which came through Joel, as they came through Jesus, Buddha, Shankara, Lao Tsu. This is the holy Word brought to us in our day. It is not just the teaching of any ordinary person expressing their thoughts and feelings gleaned from philosophies they like. 

The Infinite Way stands alone in the world today. May you have the spiritual perception needed to see this.

Stephenson and Sinkler Open Flood Gates

 "Norman Letter" Suppressed by Leaders

The Norman Letter was suppressed in the student body until now.   In 1964, every student who corresponded with  Joel got a copy. Everyone who got the Monthly Letter got the instruction in the April 1964 Letter. All teachers and practitioners on Deb Tru's IW directory received an email with this letter last year. The suppression continued.

In 1972 Virgina Stephenson was the first to record her lectures against this direction. But it took Lorraine Sinkler to open the flood gates:

Lorraine Sinkler, 1981 on tape

"I waited a long time, but I was well aware of that letter and I know some of you are thinking, "How did you dare to do that when you had that letter?

"But, you see, I had a wonderful teacher. I had a teacher who taught me the real meaning of The Infinite Way, who taught me that there is no authority except the authority of your own inner consciousness. 

"I was so well taught that I couldn't be fooled by such a letter."

Lorraine Sinkler started recording in the 1980's after the lawsuit. Until then, Lorraine taught with Joel's tapes. Using Joel's tapes becomes dangerous if you are not following his principles. Soon, the students discover what is going on and your "cottage-tape-industry" suffers.

The "Letter to Norman"  is emmensely important document for it is one of the final and only directions formally given by Joel His other instructions are on the tapes for Teachers and Practitioners. Today, we have many people advertising that they are teachers of Joel Goldsmith (for it is illegal to us the The Infinite Way without permission of the Office in Arizona - this site was created for the Geri MacDonald with permission many years ago and remains dedicated to supporting Joel's instructions although we are not affiliated in any way with the business of The Infinite Way.) 

Because of the confusion for students new to the work and not aware of Joel's directions, we have made this list. It is not meant to be critical. It is simply a vehicle for students to recognize what is and is not Infinite Way.  It would be like  looking for 2+2=4, but encountering 5. We do not care about 5 and its behavior, except when it masquerades as 4. Then we have to take make a statement of fact. 2+2 is 4, not 5.  

If you are a student or teacher of Joel Goldsmith, you are expected to study/teach The Infinite Way with his tapes and books. This is his wish. If we honor his instructions, we are "4".  If you do not, you are "5".  It is very straight forward. Joel's letter made it very easy. (If you make tapes, you have a choice to stop or continue.)

This is not to say that there will never be more truth in the world than what Joel brought forth. Surely, we expect it one day. However, it is the responsibility of the new revelator to give his teaching a new name. This is only fair to Joel and to the students. 

If teachers have nothing new, they are teaching what they have learned from Joel. Why withhold from your students the same vehicle you had : Joel - his tapes and books? If you have something new to teach, then do it with your name and explain how it is different.  Obviously, it will not be The Infinite Way.

Jesus took issue with the moneychangers of the Temple.  In that same vein, we find we must turn over the tables and expose those who appear as Infinite Way, but indeed have personal goals, goods, or agendas.  We hope you will join us in blessing all and  knowing their true  spiritual identities.

We know that Grace operates and "protects" The Infinite Way, but God does not operate in the world. IT must operate through us. We offer ourselves as transparencies for ITs work. May we serve with a Christ Consciousness at all times.

On tape 520, Joel tells us of the importance of "correction."  Teachers of this work must be willing and able to make corrections to the wrong understanding of the message. It is in this spirit that we offer this section of the site.

We have been asked  to help students find their way through the current confusion in The Infinite Way. We pray for the awakening of all mentioned here to the directions JOEL gave his teachers.


Here are links to sites which sell so-called Infinite Way tapes and writings but are made by others, not Joel Goldsmith.  All have been sent copies of "The Letter to Norman."

Many will claim successorship through parents (Stephenson, Ponga), or Joel's introduction years ago. Better to look at the "fruits" of their work and their healings.  Infinite Way teachers must have a healing consciousness, teach and impart meditation, not just know the philosophy of the words.  (John Stephenson has said, "I do not heal, I only teach.  My mother has does the healing work.")

Be aware of the use of excuses for not using Joel's tapes in class. If a teacher does not use Joel's tapes and books exclusively (exceptions would be passages from the Bible and other revealed scripture from Buddha, Gita, Lao Tsu, etc.), they are saying to you that their individual consciousness is greater than Joel's. Anyone who does not recognize the level of Joel's refined consciousness, cannot possibly impart the consciousness of The Infinite Way to you. 

.

http://www.valorfoundation.com :

Photographs and Name Legacy (Valborg and Lorraine = Valor)

Valor Foundation is dedicated to Lorraine Sinkler (original student of Joel) and her writings and tapes.  Be very careful with Sinkler's teachings regarding freedom.

http://www.alohamystics.com

Photographs of Virginia and John Stephenson

Site containing the tapes and publications of Virginia Stephenson (original student of Joel) and her son, John.

http://www.lorenemcclintock.com


 Photographs

Site selling materials created by Lorene McClintock, one of original students of Joel . Joel did approve of  Ms. McClintock's study course and signed a legal statement to that effect. The outline is the only permitted work.

http://home.planet.nl-index.html

Photographs

It is with great regret I post a long-time friend, Bertus Rabe. The support for "freedom" to do whatever we want because he is loyal to Lorraine Sinkler is unacceptable. I will hold Bertus close in prayer for he has been very kind to me.

http://infinite-invisible.net/index.html
    

Joel S. Goldsmith Study Group of Chicago

http://www.theunofficialinfiniteway.com

Uses Photographs of Joel

Website which denies being Infinite Way. Has changed into a site for A Course in Miracles. In the name of Joel  and The Infinite Way, mixes Absolute teachings, Course in Miracles, Unity, Tolle, Williamson, etc., offers chatroom discussion and debate.

Mantras: "Nothing happens except in your own consciousness."  This is a quote of Joel's taken out of context to excuse any and every erroneous thought or behavior. 

"We are free as a bird." This is a quote from Lorraine Sinkler used as license to do anything they wish in the name of The Infinite Way.

http://www.instillness.com

Independent site selling tapes, etc. made by owner.     

http://www.leelaa.org/Herb%20Fitch%2089_90.htm

Promotes tapes of Herb Fitch with photo

http://www.esnips.com/web/HerbFitchThunderofSilence1974

Promotes tapes of Herb Fitch and Deb Tru who claims to be Infinite Way and Christian Science.

http://www.freewebs.com/iwstudents/


 Independent site containing materials by others inconsistent with The Infinite Way.  Distortions and changes to IW teachings. Supporters of Sinkler philosophy and Sinkler teacher, Julia Davidson.

Includes many photographs

http://www.freewebs.com/iwstudents/juliadavidson.htm

"Iwstudents" site promotes and encourages going against Joel's instructions.  Lots of photos.

 Julia Davidson and her husband were attorneys who helped Lorraine Sinkler with her lawsuit against Emma Goldsmith. Please use caution when others recommend in ignorance of history and truth.

"In the early 1990's Julia engaged a company to create an Infinite Way website for herself. A polite phone call requesting cooperation to remove the site in the interest of The Infinite Way was met with enormous resistance, severe replies and legal threats.  Refusal to cooperate ended only when legal rights were presented to her webmaster."   (Personal account of IW office worker at the time.)

http://www.inwaynz.com

Infinite Way site in New Zealand which sells tapes by others. Supporters of Virginia Stephenson. Photos

http://www.mysticalprinciples.com

Independent site incorporating materials by others inconsistent with The Infinite Way.

http://www.beyondprayerandmeditation.com

Independent site. Widow of Robert Gupton sells books and tapes made by both of them. According to Gail Gupton, she does not teach Infinite Way or heal.

http://www.podcastdirectory.com/podshows/959795

Unidentified reader reads passage from Parenthesis and then plays Salsa music.

IW Contact Center Directory - Mary Noack & Deb Tru

October 29, 2007 we were invited to join this list. In the interest of harmony and oneness, we agreed. However, as soon as the list was viewed, it became apparent that the promise in the invitation was not being met. The following paragraph implies that this is a site for those following Joel:

"Note to Teachers and Practitioners:  It is asked of you if you use any tapes or books or any material other than that of the Infinite Way in your work, then please DO NOT sign yourself in as a teacher or practitioner. Surely you can understand that this site is not then for you as it is dedicated to those who have chosen the path of the Infinite Way."

My Letter to Mary Noack the site founder:

Dear Mary,

Best wishes on your new endeavour. Happy to see you are asking for
only IW. How about listing the Letter to Norman?  Just take it from my
site.  Also, you do not mention tapes, the 55 Kailua and then the 59
Hawaiian Healing. Please consider this for the sake of the students.
The highest consciousness is in the tape work, as you know.

I would also add that before they make ANY contact, a
student/practitioner/teacher should remember to make the connection
within for guidance. Likewise, if ever they have any question about a
person/teacher/practitioner on the list, they do the same.

Listing people is a big step for it often is understood to be
endorsement.  May you be guided to lead and make sure those on your
list are in tune with Joel and his instructions to teachers,
practitioners and students on the tapes and his "Norman" letter.

If I can be of any further help, please do not hesitate to ask/call, write.

Let us meditate and bless the furthering of The Infinite Way as Joel
presented it.

Mary's Answer:

As always thank you for your loving concern.
There are a few more things I need to compile and get to my web guy and  I
will do my best to add what you have mentioned.
  It is a small site and I will have to see how much more room I have left
for adding more items

The problem is "materials other than that of the Infinite Way."  Students must be very aware that there are those who will interpret this as the materials of Sinkler, Stephenson, or anyone who claims to be teaching IW.  The Letter to Norman clearly states ONLY books and tapes by Joel.  This is not a difficult concept, yet it continues to be misrepresented to serve individual's self interests. Please use caution.

http://www.iwstudentcontactcenter.com

Self-registering list. You will find A Course in Miracles students claiming to be IW teachers, others looking for social connection as teachers, etc.

We urge serious students to avoid this list and any others.

You will find many listed below also on this site.  Please check under our page "TEACHER: How to Find" for more information to help you discern as you decide whom to contact for help

INDIVIDUAL NAMES

This list represents those who are active with Infinite Way students. Comments cover behavior. There is no judgment of consciousness or healing ability.  This is merely a reference to check a teacher's compliance with Joel's Letter to Norman instruction.

Students expect all involved in a spiritual message to maintain the highest personal standards. Teachers expect the same of students.  However, as in any human endeavor, we find variations on understanding and professionalism. The Infinite Way is not an organization, there are very few guidelines. Therefore, please use clear judgment based on your inner communion for guidance.

Caution should be used with any teacher interested in a student for financial, emotional, or other mundane, coporeal desire. Reports have come to us about romantic involvements between students and teachers. It goes without saying that this is totally inappropriate. Each of us is clearly responsible to maintain the highest personal, ethical standards.


All will try to present themselves as Infinite Way teachers. More and more will try to insist on the correctness of their approach. "We just need to go within and let Joel's instructions guide us." This is the legacy of Lorraine Sinkler whom we recently discovered was going to be fired by Joel after his final trip to Europe which Joel did not complete.  Clearly, Joel understood Lorraine's new found independence.  Those listed have notations about their activities so that you can easily measure their cooperation with Joel's instructions.


The Letter to Norman says exactly what teachers should do and what we students should  look for in instruction. Letter is FOR TEACHERS. It is very clear, direct and precise. No teaching but Joel's books and tapes are to be used.

Our purpose is to help Infinite Way students find their way to those who only work with Joel's tapes and writings and who support the importance of keeping Joel's message pure.  The Infinite Way is Joel's experience and revelation.  The truth of the principles being proven through healings.  If you meet an Infinite Way teacher, simply ask if they teach using Joel's tapes and books and if they do healing.  Their answers will guide you correctly.

Please let  us know if there are any corrections needed in the names below. We look forward to removing names from this list if and when they return to the instructions in The Letter to Norman written to all teachers and students in April 1964. These names are found in the catalogue of Mystics of the World and on an independent Infinite Way listing of teachers and practitioners.

We want to hear about healings, about consciousness, about meditation, not about reasons why everyone is free to express themselves as Infinite Way because all truth is truth and everyone is God.  The Infinite Way is JOEL's teaching, period. IW teachers are charged with teaching only Joel's tapes and books.  Again, if you (or anyone else in the world)  have something to add or change, great, but make sure that we all know it is YOUR idea or revelation. The only way to do that is to put your name on it....not pretend to be speaking for Joel. Please, readers, use caution and good sense when evaluating whom you would like to follow and seek guidance from.

Finally, Joel's custom was to wait for students in a city to invite him (often with a plane ticket as well).  He only posted a notice of the class for those who knew him.  He only wanted students already familiar with the work to come to class. He did not do advertising. In this light, please use caution when you are solicited to come to a "mystical" or  "Goldsmith group" class of someone claiming to be Infinite Way, but whom you have never reached out to. This is how business operates, it is marketing. Often, you will be "sold" more than you intended, perhaps even human goods or wares.

A student is drawn to a teacher by consciousness, the hand of Grace. Teachers are not to seek students. Joel made this very clear, for "My own will come to me."

 

Chris Bentley - Independent mix of Absolute, Course in Miracles, etc. Photos. http://www.infiniteway.com/unofficialinfiniteway.htm

Writings and web-posts which confuse the IW principles, Joel's message and instructions.  Chris Bentley (and associates: Simonsen, Skiles and Pilato) insists that he has the correct understanding of how The Infinite Way should be conducted. Since his teachers (Sinkler, Davidson and disciples) were those who disobeyed Joel,  these erroneous "habits" are simply being continued in his personal outreach.  Listed as IW teacher on Noack IW Contact List.

Candice Blessner - Unity

Michele Blood and Bob Proctor - prosperity metaphysicians, quote Joel.

Rafael Catala - Personal message

O. Dexter Covell - Claims spoke with Joel, but totally fictional encounter with Joel - use caution traces of Christian Science terminology and distorted understandings throughout his book,   Taking the Path of Spiritual Awakening: A Fresh Look at the Teachings of Joel S. Goldsmith.
Huge waste of time and money! 

Doris Crawford - tapes

Julia Davidson - sided with Sinkler against Emma Goldsmith. Photos

John Drewrey - tapes, book, adds business card to Joel's books in bookstore. Listed as IW teacher on Noack IWContact list.

Herb Fitch - tapes, photos.

Gail Gupton - teaches prosperity metaphysics, endorses "The Secret"

Bob Harper - sells tapes of teachers (Sinkler student). Listed as IW teacher on Noack IW Contact list.

Mary Hunt - tapes and books (Sinkler student)

Margaret Johnson - tapes

Larisan - independent mix

Ken Lazdowski - tapes, classes, book.   See Arnie Vargas, student, photos.

Leela - promotes Herb Fitch

Corey Leland - follows A Course in Miracles but listed as an IW teacher on the Contact directory.

Margaret MacFarlane - supports Ponga, Stephenson tapes and writings. Photos.

Lorene McClintock - tapes and book. Supported Emma Goldsmith in Sinkler vs. Goldsmith.  Photos.
http://www.infiniteway.com/mcclintockrecording.htm

Was given legal permission by Joel to produce her student outline. We regret that she did not stop there and remain true to Joel's instruction.  Lorene's music program and paintings are a beautiful expression of the IW principles expressing themselves in an individual.  However, because Lorene went on to write an IW book and make tapes, we must add her here. She surely knew of the Letter to Norman.  Playing tapes of her lessons in the privacy of her home is still taking students away from Joel.

Allan Marsh

http://www.bookwire.com/MeetTheAuthor/Interview_Allen_Marsh.htm

Past editor of Acropolis books. Admits to changing Joel's words to make them more "contemporary" - see introduction to Foundations in Mysticism. Marsh mixes several messages.  We would like to believe this is merely out of ignorance of the principles of The Infinite Way. Perhaps with more tape study, mistakes in his teachings will be corrected. We look forward to this in the future, for Marsh is well liked as a person.

The Hawaiian Hotel Talks: Consciousness In Transition were not published in their original form. Words have been changed and omitted throughout.

A glaring example of a mistake is the following:

In a  letter  dated Dec. 27, 2006, Marsh suggests the book, Anna, Grandmother of Jesus.

"Anna, Grandmother of Jesus " by Claire Heartsong - This book talks about those who surrounded Jesus (his family and students, and their importance to his training and accomplishments.) It is a channeled book.

Marsh, it seems, has not studied Joel's lessons on Dominion nor read what he writes about students studying Christian history.   Had Marsh studied Dominion, he would understand that we never give our dominion to another, nor do we ever impose our consciousness on another.  (This is the lesson regarding only accepting a request for help from the patient directly.)  The entire practice of channeling and "keeping an open mind, so anything can crawl in" would be antithetical to Joel.  We "tile" at the door of our consciousness.  We practice Protective Work.  We are not metaphysicians, magicians, or psychics.

Joel wrote to Barbara Muhl, one of his teachers (not mentioned on "the tape," yet a very close student and teacher), that he did not want teachers of The Infinite Way teaching Christian history as the Bible had many mistakes.  Students, he said, would be better off using their time on the principles. Ancient history is unclear about Jesus. The Dead Sea Scrolls are the closest factual accounts of the time. Whatever we know about the Essenes is not applicable to Jesus for Joel says that Jesus left the group. (Most likely over their militant outlook and holy war teachings which we now know from Scroll scholarship.) 

IW Students, please use discernment and discretion in your choices of what appears to/or is advertised  be IW teachers, classes, lectures, etc.

John Miller - tapes and books

Margra Muirhead - tapes and books

Mary Noack - began as tape group leader, now offers classes in A Course in Miracles Center, finds students by sending free study passages.  Teaching journeys to students include selling art and cosmetics. Created the IW Contact Center with Deb Tru who mixes Christian Science with IW  

http://www.realezsites.com/bus/marybarbara/.

Luella Overeem - tapes and books. (Sinkler student.)

Alun Owen - tapes and books

Vinny Pinto - created Jean Tamborski site and implies they heal as Joel did. Their person practice branches out from there. http://www.divine-heart.org

"More recently, in the past two years, I have been exposed to the writings of Eckhart Tolle, a German-born mystic and spiritual teacher.  I agree strongly with his descriptions of inner phenomena and ways of "getting there". I recommend his book "The Power of Now " for all.  Jean Tamborski, who is also a spiritual healer, recently mentioned to me the works of Joel Goldsmith, the famed Christian mystic and healer, who passed on in the early 1960's.  A number of his books are still in print, including "The Infinite Way" and "The Art of Spiritual Healing " (both excellent books), and his words are simple and powerful.  Much like Eckhart Tolle, Lester Levenson, Robert Adams, and Jean Klein, he advises recognizing the "illusory" rules and judgements of the mind, and being willing to let them go, or at least love them for what they are. 

"Much like Lester Levenson and Robert Adams, Joel Goldsmith recommends spiritual healing primarily for its value of "demonstration" or "demonstrating" (words which all three teachers used in this sense), where the words mean precisely that: demonstrating the infinite and transcendent nature of God-ness,  or Being or Spirit (my favorites are Source or Divinity), and also demonstrating the illusory nature of mind."

Margaret Ponga - tapes and books (Sinkler student.)

Bill Poteete  - tapes and books,  photos.

Joy Powell - tapes and books

Bob Proctor - prosperity metaphysician, a star of "The Secret," quotes Joel.

Bertus Rabe-represents himself to all of Europe to be Infinite Way, but he promotes Lorraine Sinkler and Luella Overeem. Here is the Lorraine "Mantra" which is a total mis-interpretation of Joel's words: from The Contemplative Life  pp.20

"...You are under no obligation to me or to the message of The Infinite Way. There is nothing you can join, so their is no memberships or ties to dissolve...."

This is Joel speaking to every student. It is NOT permission to destroy his life's work with tampering. Lorraine felt she was "free as a bird"  which she understood was permission to break the law. Photos.

Miriam Santana - student of Titchell and Gladys Universal offering tapes of Joel with Titchell. Does not think Letter to Norman is relevant today.

Roger Simonsen - independent mix of Absolute, Unity, Course in Miracles, and Metaphysical teachings. Deliberately undermining Joel's instructions. Participants of chat room disparage Joel. Site uses photo of Joel. http://www.infiniteway.com/unofficialinfiniteway.htm

Lorraine Sinkler - close teacher, editor of Goldsmith writings who was entrusted with teaching the student body after Joel died. Unfortunately, ended her illustrious career by suing Emma Goldsmith, creating the organization of The Valor Foundation, and leaving her name on a building at a college.  Her students were given a legacy of unconditional freedom and license with The Infinite Way. Photos.
http://www.infiniteway.com/sinklerlorraine.htm 
http://www.infiniteway.com/editingsinklerhorizons.htm  
http://www.infiniteway.com/sinklervsgoldsmithtrial.htm  
http://www.infiniteway.com/thespiritualjourneyof.htm 

Dulcie Smith - tapes and books

Walter Starcke - has a book about Joel remembering a time when he was as student. Starcke did not understand Joel's teaching and now has his own teaching, a combining of material and spiritual realms. Photos.

John Stephenson - tapes and books (son of Virgina Stephenson). Joel says we cannot inherit consciousness. Family ties are nice, but should not be considered "ordination" in any way. When asked in 2007 whether he heals, John replied, "I don't heal. I just teach." Photos.

Virginia Stephenson - tapes and books, sided with Sinkler against Emma Goldsmith. 
Adopted another teacher's use of "aloha" to develop "Aloha Mystics."  Freedom is sometimes license. Photos.
http://www.infiniteway.com/virginiastephenson.htm

Jean Tamborski -

Jean's work is based primarily upon the spiritual foundations offered by the late Christian mystic and teacher Joel Goldsmith, as described in his life's teaching work called "The Infinite Way".  Much like Joel Goldsmith's work, Jean's work is based in the sensing of the reality of the omnipresence, omnipotence and omniscience of God and of our deep, unfailing connection at all times with God, giving us access to these same qualities.  When Jean is working at first with a client, she will often use her dowsing abilibities and training to do a head-to-toe "body scan", and elicit a "reading" from 0 to 360, for the person's flow of divine light as a whole, and also a similar score for specific ares of the body.  Jean relates that a zero or near-zero means very low functioning and low consciuosness, while a score of 120 indicates to her a healthy "normal" vitality, and a score of 360 indicates a blossoming awareness and flow of love.  She sees herself as a facilitator, helping people to let go of "baggage" which they may have been unconsciously carrying for years in their mind, body or energy body.  In her release work, she often works with the assistance of angels. Jean's fee for each treatment (which may involve up to 7 sessions over a week) is $100.

http://www.divine-heart.org/jeantamborski1.html

Tony Titshall - tapes (Sinkler  student).

Deb Tru - wife of IW tape leader, Stephenson student, Rick Carr. Created IW directory which was a private mailing to participants. Discontinued and now helps Mary Noack with public, on-line list open to the public. She believes that one can mix IW with Christian Science. 

"For daily postings from THE INFINITE WAY by Joel Goldsmith and/or daily postings from CHRISTIAN SCIENCE CLASS INSTRUCTION by Arthur Corey, email debtru@cox.net "

Promoter of Herb Fitch

Gladys Universal - tapes (Sinkler student). Re-records Joel with her personal comments.

Arnie Vargas - mixes IW with yoga, chanting, reiki, conducts retreats, Ken Lazdowski student.  (Student of Joel's books for four years.)  Photos.

http://www.wiseweavers.net/whats_new_1.html
http://www.kalani.com/workshop/daring_to_be_free.html

 

"The Key to an Abundant Life,"   A weekend retreat based on the teachings of Joel S. Goldsmith.

Offered by Arnie J Vargas, ACSW

When:  From Friday eve, March 16, until Sunday afternoon, March 18,2007

Where: Alhambra Hotel, Playa del Carmen,  Mayan Riviera, Mexico

Program Description:  Join us for a brake from the Winter weather in the Mayan Riviera of Mexico, to explore the mystical teachings of Joel S Goldsmith on healing and well being.   Ideal weekend for anyone practicing, or interested in alternative healing.   Understanding the key to the principles that constitute an abundant life, and practicing those principles, is the key to effective healing and to a harmonious life.

During this weekend in this beautiful setting ( www.alhambra-hotel.net) participants will be exposed to the mystical teachings that have brought abundant life to thousands.  Among the features of the retreat will be:

*  Morning Yoga with Master Teacher: Jose Francisco Martinez,

*  Delicious food,

*  Time to enjoy the beach and surroundings,

*  Time to make new friends with others on the spiritual path,

*  The acquisiton of spiritual tools to face life's many challenges,

*  and much more...

Retreat Fee: $150  

Accommodation prices range from $61 per night, per person (4 in a room) to $151 per night for private rooms.  Double and Triple accommodations also available.  Price per room includes breakfast and buffet lunch.

For further information: Please call Arnie J Vargas at 212-721-9572 or at 609-898-4334, or via email: ajvargas44@yahoo.com .


Arnie J Vargas, ACSW

Coordinator.

About the Presenter:  Arnie J Vargas, ACSW, is a Psychoanalytically Trained Psychotherapist, Reiki Master, Shaman, Adjunct Instructor at New York University's Graduate School of Social Work (The Shirley M Ehrenkranz School of Social Work), International Teacher and Healer.   Besides conducting retreats on the teachings of Joel S Goldsmith, Arnie teaches on the connection between Sexuality and Spirituality, and various other thems from diverse Spiritual Traditions.  He maintains a private practice in New York City and in Cape May, NJ, where he resides.